Company: Apple Inc.
Industry: Technology & Consumer Electronics
Key Issues: VoiceOver screen reader, iOS accessibility, website accessibility lawsuits
Status: Industry leader with ongoing accessibility improvements
Apple Accessibility Case Study
Apple has been widely recognized as an industry leader in built-in accessibility features, yet the company has also faced legal challenges regarding accessibility compliance. This case study examines Apple's accessibility innovations alongside notable lawsuits and their implications for digital accessibility.
→
Case Overview
Key Facts
→
Accessibility Leadership
Built-in Features
Apple includes VoiceOver, Switch Control, Voice Control, and numerous other accessibility features as standard in all iOS, macOS, watchOS, and tvOS devices at no additional cost.
VoiceOver and iOS Accessibility Features
Apple's commitment to accessibility dates back to the introduction of VoiceOver in 2005. Key accessibility features include:
- VoiceOver: Built-in screen reader available across all Apple platforms, enabling blind and low-vision users to navigate devices through spoken descriptions and gestures
- Voice Control: Allows complete device control through voice commands, benefiting users with motor impairments
- Switch Control: Enables device operation through external adaptive switches for users with severe motor limitations
- Magnifier: Uses the device camera as a digital magnifying glass for low-vision users
- Live Captions: Real-time captioning for audio content on device
- AssistiveTouch: Customizable on-screen menu for users who cannot use standard touch gestures
- Sound Recognition: Alerts deaf and hard-of-hearing users to important sounds like doorbells and alarms
Key Issues: Legal Challenges and Lawsuits
Despite Apple's accessibility leadership, the company has faced notable legal challenges:
Website Accessibility Lawsuits
- 2019 ADA Lawsuits: Apple faced multiple lawsuits alleging their website apple.com contained accessibility barriers including missing alt text, inaccessible forms, and keyboard navigation issues
- App Store Accessibility: Complaints regarding third-party apps available through the App Store that lack accessibility features
- Apple TV+ Content: Initial concerns about audio descriptions availability for streaming content
Product Accessibility Concerns
- Touch Bar (2016-2021): The MacBook Pro Touch Bar was criticized by blind users for replacing tactile function keys with a touch screen that was difficult to use without visual feedback
- AirPods: Early AirPods lacked adequate accessibility features for hearing aid users, though later models added Live Listen and conversation boost
- FaceTime Accessibility: Early versions lacked proper screen reader support for deaf users who rely on sign language
Outcomes and Settlements
| Area | Outcome |
|---|---|
| VoiceOver Adoption | VoiceOver has become the most widely used mobile screen reader, setting the standard for mobile accessibility |
| Developer Guidelines | Apple requires developers to make apps accessible and provides comprehensive accessibility APIs |
| Website Improvements | Apple.com underwent accessibility improvements following legal pressure, achieving better WCAG compliance |
| Industry Influence | Apple's built-in accessibility features influenced competitors to improve their own accessibility offerings |
| Made for iPhone Program | Hearing aids with Made for iPhone certification connect directly to Apple devices with enhanced audio streaming |
Lessons Learned
→
For Technology Companies
Best Practices
- Build accessibility into products from the ground up rather than retrofitting
- Include accessibility features as standard, not as optional add-ons
- Create comprehensive accessibility APIs and require their use by third-party developers
- Establish accessibility certification programs for compatible devices
→
For All Organizations
Key Takeaways
- Even accessibility leaders must maintain vigilance over web properties
- Third-party content and platforms require accessibility oversight
- New product features should be evaluated for accessibility impact
- Engage with disability communities throughout product development